CHIEF JUSTICE'S LEGAL YEAR OPENING SPEECH 2025

CHIEF JUSTICE'S SPEECH(https://www.judicial.tc/latest/publications)

06 January 2025

Introduction

My Lords, Justices of the Supreme Court, Ms. Justice Tanya Lobban Jackson, Mr. Justice Anthony Gruchot, Mr. Justice Chris Selochan and Acting Judge Jeremy Donne, may I wish you a very good morning, and welcome you to the special sitting of the Supreme Court to mark the Opening of the Legal Year 2025.

I acknowledge the participation of the President of the Court of Appeal, The Hon. Justice of Appeal Alice Yorke Soo Hon, and Judges of the Court of Appeal who are attending this sitting virtually.

My Lords, while I stand on existing protocol, may I with your leave welcome Her Excellency the Governor, Ms. Dileeni Daniel-Selvaratnam, the Honourable Premier Mr. Washington Misick and the Cabinet of the Turks and Caicos Islands, Her Excellency the Deputy Governor Ms. Anya Williams, the Honourable Deputy Premier Mr. Jamell Robinson, the Chairperson of the Judicial Service Commission, Madame Justice Hilary Phillips, Members of the Judicial Service Commission, Madame Justice Zaila McCalla and Dame Janice Pereira, joining us remotely, Resident Magistrates their Honors, Selver-Gardiner and Arana and The Coroner H/H Mills, Professor Nick Barber who will be delivering our Sir Richard Ground OBE QC Memorial Lecture Series 2025, and Mrs. Barber, Mr. Eugene Otuonye KC, former Director of Public Prosecution and Mrs. Otuonye, and all our esteemed guests, to this special sitting of the Supreme Court for the Opening of the 2025 Legal Year.

My Lords, we follow tradition today as we do every year, to mark the official Opening of the Legal Year 2025. This year, having listened to the stories of inconvenience related to the activities marking the Opening, we have made two changes which we hope will meet with the approval of the court and our guests. The first is that we have moved the Legal Year Opening from 4 to 6 January as the former was too close to the New Year festivities and had become burdensome. The second is the curtailment of this court sitting in that the customary speeches have been sent for publication this morning, and will therefore not be delivered in their entirety. I trust that these changes meet with your approval and the approval of our stakeholders and guests.

My Lord, the Opening of the Legal Year is the highlight of the legal year of the Turks and Caicos Islands. It is celebrated with the exhibition of pomp, as we show forth the grandeur of the law and its place in the administration of justice. We give thanks for our work in the previous year and pray for divine guidance for the legal year at a church service, followed by a special sitting at which we give a report of our work, and speak of our successes as well as our challenges, and set forth our goals for the year. We then round off the day’s activities, with an elegant event dedicated to the memory of a former Chief Justice who poured himself into the Judiciary of these islands.

In doing all these, we say two things to the Turks and Caicos Islands. The first, is that we recognise the confidence you have reposed in us by entrusting us with the administration of justice in these islands. The second is that while we boast of our strengths, we acknowledge our weaknesses with humility. We give our collective word that we will strive to improve our performance in the areas in which we have faltered or have been found wanting, and we shall endeavour to live up to the country’s well-founded expectations.

This year, our departure from tradition also includes a drive to provide to the country, a holistic accounting of our work and the work of related institutions. To this end, the full Opening Speech by the Chief Justice, as well the speeches of the Hon. Attorney General, the Learned Director of Public Prosecutions, the President of the Bar Counsel, the distinguished Doyen of the Bar, the Commissioner of the Royal Turks and Caicos Islands Police Force, the Superintendent of His Majesty’s Prison, the Director of the Department of Rehabilitation and Community Services and the Director of the Department of Social Development have this morning been published on our website: judicial.tc., and have been made available to media houses. They will also be published on the websites of each reporting institution in the coming days.

With these preliminary remarks, I call attention to the fact that we have before us once again, the motion of the Honourable Attorney General of these islands as supported by the Learned Director of Public Prosecutions, the President of the Bar Council, and the Doyen of the Bar for the opening of the 2025 Legal Year. My Lords, I acknowledge the remarks brought by the Hon. Attorney General on behalf of her Chambers as well as on behalf of our stakeholder institutions. I also acknowledge the remarks of the Learned Director of Public Prosecutions, the President of the Bar Council, and the Doyen of the Bar, and I express my gratitude for their unwavering support of the Judiciary. The Judiciary of the Turks and Caicos is enriched by your constancy as we collectively pursue the goal of providing access to quality justice to all persons of these islands.

HIGHLIGHTS

The Sir Richard Ground OBE QC Memorial Lecture Series

My Lords, the legal year 2024 commenced with the Sir Richard W. Ground, OBE QC, Lecture/Dinner Series which was delivered by the Rt Hon. Sir Declan Morgan, Member of His Majesty’s Most Honourable Privy Council. The successful lecture/dinner which was attended by the judiciary and its stakeholders, was the evidence of the harmonious relationship enjoyed by the judiciary with the Bar as well as the other arms of Government and Government institutions and agencies.

Mediation Day

My Lords, the Judiciary of the Turks and Caicos Islands which remains steadfast in its commitment to “[provide] access to quality justice", moved the Judiciary forward in 2024, towards the fulfilment of its mandate in important areas. I will start with a happy event: the celebration of Mediation Day on 17 th October 2024. This was our local celebration of the global International Mediation Day, our first, since Court-Connected Mediation was introduced in these islands in 2021.

As was fitting, the first Mediation Day was dedicated to celebrating the work of our well-trained mediators who resolve disputes as part of the judiciary’s alternative dispute resolution programme; they achieve amazing settlements for persons seeking justice, outside of the walls of the courtroom.

Although access to justice through mediation is championed by the Judiciary there is room for improvement in the embrace by members of the public who, having been used to the process of litigation, are often hesitant to explore the alternative mechanism presented by court-connected mediation. We therefore, in our continuing efforts to champion mediation as a viable alternative dispute resolution mechanism, used the Mediation Day celebration to also bring more awareness to the mediation process.

Special Sitting

My Lords, the second happy event was the successful honouring ceremony by which we saw off two eminent jurists for their contribution to the jurisprudence of these Islands. In the special sitting, which was held on 27th November 2024, The Honourable Mr. Justice of Appeal Stanley John who served as a member of the Court of Appeal until 3 rd November 2024, and the Honourable Mr. Justice Davidson Baptiste who demitted office on 30 June 2024, were recognised for their exemplary work, and for their commitment to justice and to justice delivery in these Islands.

Ordinances, Rules and Regulations

My Lords, in 2024, the Judiciary continued to make improvements in the quality of its work, by issuing and updating rules and regulations to reflect the evolving needs of the Turks and Caicos Islands. These are:

The Bail Bill:

In 2021, I set up a committee to introduce the first Bail Ordinance to provide guidance and a level of certainty to the grant and refusal of bail in these islands. The composition of the Committee has changed over the years, but I am happy to report that in December 2024, I finally received a draft Bail Bill which I submitted to the Attorney General’s Chambers for progressing. I thank all the persons who worked on this committee, and will in due course, acknowledge them by name along with others who have worked on other legislation committees.

The Legal Profession (Admissions and Other Procedures) Regulations 2024.

In consultation with the Bar Council, and with the approval of Her Excellency the Governor in Cabinet, I published these regulations which came into force on 1 November 2024. The Regulations provide some certainty in the process by which persons trained in the law will be admitted to practise before the courts on the Turks and Caicos Islands, whether as members of the Bar admitted to practise generally, or as persons admitted to advise, or appear in cases on a limited admission. The Regulations also provide for the circumstances under which the Bar Council may take over the law practice of an attorney who for specified reasons, can no longer work as an attorney. This power provides protection to members of the public when attorneys to whom they entrust their legal affairs and cases are no longer in a position to perform their duties towards their clients.

Probate and Administration (Non-Contentious) Rules 2024

The niggling issues related to probate and administration of the estate of deceased persons are being tackled with Rules that will put to bed matters that have caused anxiety to personal representatives of deceased persons. The Probate and Administration Rules 2024, deal with non-contentious probate and seek to streamline procedures for dealing with the estates of deceased persons. It is hoped that in a few weeks, the second part of the Rules which deal with contentious probate and administration matters will also be published.

Contempt of Court Rules 2024

These seek to bring discipline and to correct as well as to punish behaviour that would undermine the administration of justice.

The Legal Aid (Amendment) Rules 2024

These provide further guidance on eligibility for legal aid. They are aimed at improving the administration of legal aid as the judiciary seeks to aid poor persons to access quality justice while we protect the public purse.

Practice Direction 1 of 2024 provides procedures for the enforcement of decisions and awards of the Labour Tribunal. It is aimed at filling the gap between the awards of the Labour Tribunal and the realisation of the said awards.

Judicial Handbook for Staff

In May 2024, the Judiciary published the Handbook for Judicial Staff, to provide guidance to all judicial staff for improved performance and the proper discharge of their duties. The handbook provides a comprehensive overview of key concepts, procedures, and best practices in judicial administration. Regarding procedures, information is provided on court office procedures at all levels of the court, as well as the conduct of mediations. The handbook also contains information on how to maintain professionalism, collegiality, communication within the institution, and the management of conflicts among members of staff. The Judiciary’s core values of excellence of output, accountability, responsiveness in service, independence, integrity and impartiality are explained. The provision of this handbook in staff protocol development was successfully, but softly, launched. It is my hope that the goal of improving efficiency and integrity in justice delivery will be achieved and maintained with this work.

Judicial Education

My Lords, Judicial Education in the Turks and Caicos Islands continues to soar to attain new heights. In 2024, JEI delivered the two mandatory trainings for Justices of the Peace and also provided training to the Bar at their request on Probate Matters, and Civil Advocacy.

In February 2024, the JEI organised training for judges and magistrates on the topic of Judicial Comportment, which was delivered by Justice Baptiste.

In March, training was organised for the Bar on Civil Advocacy which was delivered by Mr. Ian Wilkinson KC and Mr. Tim Prudhoe. The Hon Justice Ian Morley KC, Mr Oliver Smith KC and Ms Lara Maroof delivered training on Criminal Advocacy.

In that same month, Justices of the Peace received training on the topics of “The Workings of the Liquor Licensing Authorities” delivered by Mr. Ricardo Don Hue Gardiner and “An Introduction to Criminal Legal Concepts” delivered by Mr. Clement Joseph.

In May training on “The Proceeds of Crime” was delivered by presenters from the Eastern Caribbean Supreme Court Antigua, the Asset Recovery Unit, Barbados, the National Center for State Courts, Barbados and Jamaica, delivered training on “The Proceeds of Crime”.

In the third week of September 2024 (the week of 16-20 September 2024), the JEI treated the Judiciary and its stakeholders to a festival of learning and ideas. Accomplished and distinguished presenters from around the region as far as Brazil, and from Canada, provided training for the Bench, Judicial Staff, the Bar, and Justices of the Peace.

Judges, Magistrates and members of the Bar received training on Artificial Intelligence, Environmental Issues, Anti-Money Laundering legislation, processes and best practices, how we can incorporate procedures into justice delivery for Vulnerable Groups, and how judges, and magistrates may engage social media in decision. Learning was also provided on Courtroom Management and Avoidable Delays, Judgment Writing in Criminal Cases/Extempore Judgments and Summations, as well as Disclosure in Criminal Cases. We washed the enjoyable fare down with a lecture on safeguarding our Mental Wellness in the stressful occupations that keep the wheels of justice oiled and turning.

Our hardworking Judicial Staff also received refresher training on “Court Procedures”, and Justices of the Peace, received training on “Warrants and Judicial Ethics”.

JEI looks forward to implementing an exciting training calendar this year. The hope is that we will do some in person trainings as well as our signature webinars which will be done quarterly.

JEI Week 2025 also promises a wide array of important topics which will I am sure, surpass any JEI week we have had so far. We thank all our presenters as well as our participants. You keep us going.

In 2025 we will also be organising seminars on behalf of our stakeholders who have requested them. JEI will always be at your service, to provide the tools necessary for improved legal and judicial work. To that end, the Judicial Education Committee encourages all to visit our website dedicated to judicial education at jei.tc . There, one will find presentations long forgotten but helpful as refreshers for persons who have participated in our training seminars. For those who have not, you will be amazed at the store of knowledge available to you at the click of a button. The goal is to provide access to knowledge and by it, to deliver quality justice in these islands.

Law Reporting TCILII, WIR, JUST-CONNECT

My Lords, I am happy to note that our internet reporting website TCILII which is linked to global resources and provides free access to legal material, continues to enrich the research of judges, magistrates, Registrars and attorneys. TCILII is a compendium of judgments and other sources of law and provides links to primary legal material, including updated legislation. It is also the source of first-hand information on judgments given by our courts. The posting of judgments as soon as they are delivered also provides details of case outcomes for accurate media reporting, an invaluable tool that aids in the proper dissemination of information. The website continues to garner interest internationally and puts our judiciary on the Legal Information Institutes (LII) map worldwide.

With great pride I inform my Lords that our cases continue to be reported in the West Indian Reports. Volume 104, the latest volume reports two of our judgments. It is commendable that since the Turks and Caicos Island’s judiciary joined the editorial board, our judgments are regularly reported in every volume since Volume 99.

I am also happy to report that the Judiciary of the Turks and Caicos Islands joined six (6) of its regional partners, Belize, Barbados, The Commonwealth of The Bahamas, Eastern Caribbean, Guyana and Trinidad and Tobago, in signing on to JustConnect which is a unique collaborative on-line training platform that will benefit the Caribbean region and which will significantly increase judicial training opportunities in the region. Four of our judicial offers: Justice of Appeal Hylton, Justice Selochan, H/H Ms. Arana and H/H Ms. Mills have been appointed to serve on the various Committees which will no doubt foster regional integration. Our Judiciary welcomes this initiative which will advance the administration of justice in the Caribbean through the shared delivery of high quality virtual judicial education.

North Caicos Magistrate Court

It is my belief, that until the Judiciary’s resources enable us to take justice to the doorstep of every citizen, resident, and visitor to this country, we are far from fulfilling our mandate of providing access to quality justice for all the people in the Turks and Caicos Islands. In this regard, I am pleased to announce that we now have in North Caicos, a Magistrate’s Court which is a dedicated space for the delivery of justice to the people of North and Middle Caicos. We are in the process of procuring space in the court building which will enable the decentralisation of Mediation, Restorative Justice and the Coroner’s Court.

It is hoped also that the Judiciary’s quest for a Magistrate’s Court at South Caicos which will enable us to provide decentralised services through judicial kiosks for E Judiciary, will receive due attention.

Regional and International Conferences:

My Lords, In 2024, the members of the judiciary represented the Turks and Caicos Islands at several conferences. These conferences provide a unique platform for us to exchange ideas on best practices, legal reforms, and emerging challenges within the judicial system as well as to keep up-to-date on the latest developments in law and jurisprudence, and enhancing knowledge skills. The Turks and Caicos Islands Judiciary has certainly benefited from networking opportunities which should lead to valuable partnerships within the region and around the world.

In February 2024, at the invitation of the FIDA Grand Bahama Chapter, I attended Grand Bahama Chapter Installation 2024 to present the keynote address entitled “The Practice of the Law – Reclaiming its Pride, Purpose and Place” at the Installation Dinner held in Freeport, Bahamas.

I also, in June of 2024, participated in the Annual Regional Chief Justices and Heads of Judiciaries Conference which took place in Kingston Jamaica and was attended by all Heads of Judiciary. of The two-day conference provided valuable insights on effective court administration as well as the use of technology in adjudication. The topics on which presentations were made included “C rafting an Effective Communication Strategy for the Judiciary in an era of Social Media and AI” and “Effective Strategic Planning and Risk Management in a Changing Court Environment”.

In April 2024, the Hon. Mr. Justice Gruchot attended the 5th full meeting of The Standing International Forum of Commercial Courts (‘SIFFoCC). The meeting was held at Qatar University, Qatar, and was hosted by Qatar and the Qatar International Court and Dispute Resolution Centre (‘QICDRC’). A total of 57 jurisdictions were represented at the meeting at which keynote addresses touched on several pertinent areas including ‘Developing the Relationship between Commercial Courts, Arbitration and Mediation’.

In September 2024 together with the Hon. Mr. Justice Selochan, I represented the Judiciary at the Commonwealth Magistrates’ and Judges Association (CMJA) conference held in Kigali, Rwanda. The conference brought together judicial officers from forty-three countries in the Commonwealth and covered a number of topics of current importance. I presented a paper on a panel that discussed gender-based violence as a sub-theme of the conference theme of “Environmental Justice”.

Also in September 2024, the Registrar of the Supreme Court went on a two-week immersive training program at the Royal Court of Justice in the United Kingdom on the Taxation of Costs and other matters. It is hoped that this training as well as training I hope to source for judges and Magistrates in the United Kingdon will improve our adjudication skills, courtroom practice, and judgment writing.

In November 2024, Justice of Appeal Bernard Turner, led a team of three Judicial Officers, as well as the Court Administrator to the 8th Biennial Conference of the Caribbean Association of Judicial Officers on behalf of the Judiciary.

E Judiciary

My Lords I can report that the implementation of E Judiciary is now very well advanced at all the courts. There has been a successful roll-out of this paperless system at the Supreme Court and Court of Appeal. The implementation at the Magistrate’s Court is on-going. We still have some issues with the kiosk system of decentralisation due to infrastructural difficulties.