CALL : 732-557-0200
EMAIL : info@irre.org
Home(https://irre.org) >
Blogs & Media(https://irre.org/posts/) >
Bridging the Knowing-Doing Gap
Bridging the Knowing-Doing Gap(https://irre.org/posts/bridging-the-knowing-doing-gap/)
"Will" or "Skill?"
Posted by : Randall Lobur(https://irre.org/author/randall-lobur)
Topics : Leadership(https://irre.org/tags/leadership) , Professional Learning(https://irre.org/tags/professional-learning) , Coaching(https://irre.org/tags/coaching)
When asked to support folks in implementing something new, coaches in a variety of fields are aware of the “knowing-doing gap” - the idea that individuals are often aware of the best practice, but for a variety of reasons, do not find success in implementing that practice. This situation tends to result in frustration; for those who supervise the individual, for those who the individual interacts with as peers, and perhaps most importantly, for the individual themselves. Our unique experience as instructional coaches has made us keenly aware that “the gap between knowing and doing is more famously vast in education than in any other profession" (Hall & Simeral, 2008)(http://www.ascd.org/Publications/Books/Overview/Building-Teachers-Capacity-for-Success.aspx). How, then, might we work to close it?
Before any attempt to close the gap, instructional leaders and coaches must first work to identify the type of gap that exists. In our experience, there are two varieties of knowing-doing gap: in some cases, teachers are aware of a best practice, yet lack the skill base to implement it. In other cases, teachers have both the theoretical and practical knowledge to implement best practices yet lack the will to do so. This knowing-doing gap is often narrow; teachers who are proficient in other areas find themselves with a gap in a certain area they find hard to overcome.
Before any attempt to close the gap, instructional leaders and coaches must first work to identify the type of gap that exists.
Skill-based Gap
In cases where there is a “skill” gap, teachers can articulate the rationale behind a practice (an essential first step) but need support to implement it effectively. For example, many teachers experience this when first implementing Peer Conversations; they know that students should be asked to talk to each other and paraphrase, yet the practice is sometimes ineffective as the teacher is not yet able to facilitate structured academic talk. Frustration ensues and the strategy does not become an integral part of their practice if no other supports are available.
Much like any other learner, teachers in this situation would benefit from additional learning and practice related to the target skill. This might take the form of a professional learning opportunity in which they participate in an exemplary use of the strategy, and then deeply explore the structure of the strategy in a debriefing conversation. Similarly, the teacher might also find value in observing the modeling of the practice and engaging in a reflective conversation that explores the successes and challenges of implementation.